Bring some pencils and a paper and draw each other's faces...but you add different twists, for one of these we got 3 minutes of face looking then had to turn around and had 5 to draw. This one usually gets laughs as you show off your "art skills"
You make cookies together, but one person is blindfolded. You have to work together and communicate in order for the cookies to turn out. This is especially fun when you are a little more comfortable with one another because you can help lead and direct them. When I did this date we ended up getting cookie dough all over each other, but it was super fun and totally worth it.
You drive to green canyon hot spring. It’s a 30 minute drive from Rexburg and you can spend the day there. They also have a small cage too.